Ancient Bird Fossil Smaller than a Hummingbird Discovered in Amber Trove

The teeny skull, from a bed of 99 million-year-old fossils from Myanmar, suggests bird diversity was vast before the dinosaurs went extinct.

UPDATE July 27, 2020: Last week, on July 22, the authors , published in听Nature, describing this听fossil as a dinosaur. Later analysis suggested it was a lizard. If it's a lizard, and not a dinosaur, that means it was not an ancient听bird. Please read this story with caution.

When paleontologist first examined the piece of amber, he knew he had something special on his hands. Trapped inside the 99 million-year-old hunk of fossilized coniferous tree resin, which weighs about as much as a ping-pong ball, was a teeny skull smaller than a U.S. penny. It looked听like 鈥渁 tiny arrow,鈥 he says. 鈥淚t was too strange. With a long beak and big eyes, only birds have such characteristics.鈥

He showed a photo of the specimen to his former research advisor Xu Xing, a professor at the Chinese Academy of the Sciences in Beijing who has and specializes in those with feathers. 鈥淎fter watching the photo for two or three minutes without talking, he kept thinking, and then told me that this is a very special specimen,鈥 says Lida Xing, who鈥檚 also based in Beijing at the China University of Geosciences. 鈥淗e was very surprised.鈥 (Lida sent written comments over email, as he鈥檚 currently under quarantine for coronavirus in a town with poor cellular service.)

The paleontologists were so impressed because the specimen听was smaller than any they'd seen听from the Mesozoic era鈥攖he age of dinosaurs, which stretched from 250 to 65 million years ago and includes the Triassic, Jurassic, and Cretaceous periods. Named Oculudentavis khaungraae, the fossil is one-sixth the size of the next-biggest known fossil bird. What鈥檚 more, the skull is slighter than that of the Bee Hummingbird, the most diminutive bird living today which听lays eggs the size of coffee beans in a one-inch nest. Somehow, this ancient bird was even smaller.

The find is the latest from .听Known as a Lagerst盲tte, or 鈥渕other lode鈥 in German, this fossil bed serves as an unparalleled window into life in a tropical forest 99 million years ago.听At this site, Lida Xing has personally discovered a bird hatchling and feathered dinosaur tail encased in amber. Other researchers have found , as well as lizards, frogs, snakes, snails, and various听insects. This sort of fragile, miniscule material, which is rarely fossilized, is revolutionizing our view of avian life before the mass extinction event that killed the dinosaurs.

鈥淚t鈥檚 really fascinating, the stuff we鈥檙e getting out of this amber,鈥 says , an avian paleontologist at Centre University in Kentucky who was not involved in the new research. 鈥淚t backs up something that I鈥檝e thought for ages, which is that birds had a crazy radiation in the Mesozoic.鈥

For a long time, scientists believed that birds were a relatively new invention when an asteroid struck Mexico鈥檚 Yucatan Peninsula and wiped out all other dinosaurs. But these new finds, Falk says, suggest that there was a diverse array of ancient birds听that lived alongside the dinosaurs. Their lightweight bones, as well as soft parts like skin and feathers, simply weren鈥檛 preserved like the enormous dinosaur skeletons on display in听museum halls.

鈥淭he sheer amount of diversity we had in the Cretaceous, in Aves [the order of birds], is amazing,鈥 she says. 鈥淵ou had birds doing all kinds of stuff. We even had even really tiny birds like we have today.鈥

翱肠耻濒耻诲别苍迟补惫颈蝉,听which means eye-tooth bird,听has some unusual features for birds of its time, including听two outsize eye sockets.A听commentary published alongside suggests that the eye structure 鈥減rovides strong evidence that Oculudentavis was active in well-lit, daytime environments.鈥 The skull has a long beak lined with numerous tiny teeth on both the upper and lower jaw. Based on that, 鈥渋t鈥檚 a safe assumption to say this thing is eating arthropods鈥 such as insects, Falk says. The beak and skull are too fragile to crack open seeds, and while fossil dinosaurs with this many teeth often eat fish, 鈥渨ith something this small, I don鈥檛 think that鈥檚 a feasible option,鈥 she says. 鈥淏ut they鈥檇 be great for crunching through a beetle carapace.鈥

Unfortunately, the skull is all we have. Falk, who specializes in dinosaur feet, wishes she could see its hindlimbs. 鈥淭he feet can tell you a lot about what kind of life habit it had,鈥 whether it lived in trees, on the ground, or swam. Likewise, she鈥檇 love to see the wings. 鈥淚s it an aerial insectivore?鈥 Falk asks. 鈥淲e don鈥檛 know because we don鈥檛 have the wings.鈥

Its appearance, though, makes it pretty clear that it鈥檚 a bird, and the paleontologists placed the fossil in the family of Aves on a suggested family tree. Though, to them, the distinction between bird and dinosaur isn鈥檛 so grand. 鈥淏irds are dinosaurs,鈥 Lida Xing says. 鈥淏ut this specimen is so special. In fact, it has some characteristics that do not belong to birds or even dinosaurs.鈥