New Evidence Suggests Birds ’Surf the Green Wave’ While Migrating

In a recent study, scientists found that some birds favor stopover and wintering locations with higher concentrations of vegetation.

As summer turns to fall, many European birds begin to prepare for their听long migratory听flights听south. But some have a longer journey than others.听A few of the most impressive migrators鈥攖he Common Cuckoo, the Red-backed Shrike, and the Thrush Nightingale鈥攂egin听in Northern Europe and fly听to Sub-Saharan Africa,听where they'll spend their winters foraging on bugs and seeds before returning in the spring.

Researchers have always inferred migration patterns based on where birds wind up, but identifying the motivations that underlie migrating birds' decisions has proven difficult.听Since biologists have historically been unable to track individual animals, it's been hard to say why they choose to stop in any听one spot over another. As such, scientists have听long suspected听that some birds "surf the green wave," following the growth of new plant life as they move about. But proving this idea has been difficult. In recent years, though, innovations in tracking technology have allowed听researchers such as听Kasper Thorup of the Natural History Museum of Denmark to see whether these听hunches are correct. As it turns out, evidence suggests they are.

To better understand why birds migrate the way they do, Thorup and his colleague tracked听38 cuckoos, shrikes, and nightingales听from听Southern Scandinavia to their destinations throughout听Africa. On the eight cuckoos, they used radio telemetry tags, which could be tracked by orbiting satellites. And for the 18 shrikes and 12 nightingales, they used loggers that measure light levels. Using recorded information about sunrise and sunset on each day, the researchers could then calculate the bird's latitude and longitude.

These species weren't just important for the study because they听migrate long distances鈥攖hey also migrate alone. Many birds听simply follow the leader, but听these birds must make movement decisions by themselves. So,听by comparing their migration routes with satellite-derived estimates of vegetation, Thorup could discern听what features of the landscape the birds were using to guide their movements.

As suspected, he found that during the autumn migration birds weren't simply sticking to a certain preferred climate. The birds selected their wintering sites based on local resources, and when those conditions changed, they found new foraging grounds nearby. But the birds used different strategies to do it. The results were published recently听in the journal听.

According to the study, the cuckoos preferred wintering in places that had high vegetation density, or "greenness," all year long. Shrikes and nightingales wintered instead in spots with higher-than-average greenness only while they were present. Unlike the Cuckoos, they migrated to places with vegetation density that changed seasonally. The researchers say that the two strategies could be related to the birds' foraging preferences:听Cuckoos eat insect larvae while nightingales gobble up smaller arthropods听and shrikes prefer feasting on adult insects. Each of these invertebrates might be more likely to occur in areas of low or high vegetation seasonality, respectively.

As some of the most mobile animals on the planet, birds have different habitat requirements than terrestrial migrators. Wildlife corridors鈥攖racts of land听connecting听habitats separated by human activity鈥攁re typically considered the domain of听. But birds require connectivity, too. It's just that their corridors might听allow for patches of habitat separated by hundreds of miles.

A better understanding of such听migratory听preferences could help scientists and conservationists听predict how birds will be affected by听climate change.听As Sub-Saharan Africa adjusts to warmer temperatures, these avian migrators may have听trouble locating suitable sites for overwintering. "It's likely that climate change will mean that the distribution of seasonal resources will change, and there is a chance that this will disrupt bird migration," Thorup says. "In 80 or 100 years' time, things will look different from how they look now.鈥

Whether the听birds would听be able to react to these changes and听choose new stopover or wintering听sites is not known.听Biologist听, a postdoc at the University of Ottawa, says that it isn't clear from the data whether the birds are actively selecting these听sites or they simply have an innate preference for a certain sort of vegetation density. "We cannot say that the birds are selecting sites on the basis of their greenness, simply that there is a significant correlation between site greenness and the individuals' presence at specific times," she says. If the birds' innate migration decision-making strategies are flexible enough, however, then perhaps they could revise their travel routes should they ever need to.听

In the meantime, Frei is excited by Thorup's research for other听reasons. She'd like to see his听methodology used for听pinpointing areas where bird migration sites do听not听currently coincide with optimal habitats. "Are these ecological traps where birds simply must return, despite being unsuitable?" she says. For example,听听stop each year in Central California to rest and refuel on their long journeys, but听agricultural fields have replaced the wetlands they prefer.听By finding these mismatched landscapes, ecologists could听identify and restore听critical sites for migratory听birds as they make their way across the country or world.听