When Women Run the Bird World

For decades female birders have been the silent majority. Now they鈥檙e starting their own movements to transform a privileged culture.

On the surface, birding might seem like neutral ground鈥攁n activity that any curious, nature-loving person can enjoy, regardless of age or gender. Go on a hike with your local ornithological club and at least half the attendees will be women. Circle the marsh with your binoculars听and you鈥檒l probably see a woman doing the same.

But female birders don鈥檛 always feel comfortable in the field, even with the rising听awareness . Many of us keep on despite frequent put-downs and hostility, enduring dismissive comments about our knowledge and in the worst cases, sexual harassment. I鈥檝e had men touch my hips to correct my perfectly fine birding stance. A ranger at a national wildlife refuge winked and told me about his 鈥渂ig, loaded gun.鈥 My friends have been propositioned in parks and stalked by drivers along country roads. Not even a 16-year-old can bird in peace without commenters .

Like most matters of importance, women have been integral to birding from the get-go. Female ornithologists drew attention to avifauna in the late 1800s, and suffragists helped the movement take off in the early 1900s. Today, 42 percent of U.S. birders . Personally, female birders have run my world ever since I picked up a field guide in college. My ornithology professor was a woman. My boss at 探花精选 is a woman, as are most of my colleagues throughout the office. My birding circle is mainly members of the Feminist Bird Club.

And yet men have the loudest voices and the most power in the industry. The closer you get to the top of the birding, conservation, and academic ranks, the more the gender balance tips. At 探花精选, for instance, the membership is 72 percent female, but the executive staff is 75 percent male鈥攁nd the organization has never had a female president in its 114 years. This pattern persists industry wide. Men hold the highest positions at the American Birding Association, the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, and the American Bird Conservancy. They dominate bookshelves, festivals, competitions, and gear and travel ads. They build their reputations and livelihoods around the practice and reap the greatest profits.

Gender Representation At Major Bird Organizations

探花精选

American Birding Association

American Bird Conservancy

American Ornithological Society

BirdLife

Cornell

Gay Birders of North America

Ohio Young Birders Club

Staff

Board

Director

is 60% female and 40% male.

For birding to be equal, we need more women in charge鈥攁nd that's a change we're finally starting to see. Female leaders around the world are launching听clubs and businesses that not only offer a safe space to bird, but also spread the wealth and agency to those who鈥檝e long been discounted.

Judith Mirembe, Kimberly Kaufman, Molly Adams, and the founding members of The Phoebes are just a few examples of women trying to transform the community from its core. As most of them told us in interviews, the goal isn鈥檛 to split the birding world by gender; it鈥檚 2019 and we鈥檝e fought too hard against misogyny on all fronts to do that. The point is to gain parity, educate against prejudices, add new dimensions to the sport we love, and bring men along with us as we try to create a better, safer culture for everyone.

If men aren鈥檛 down with that, we ask them to please step aside so that we, the women, can get to work. 鈥Purbita Saha, Associate Editor

Graphics by Alex Tomlinson; research by Lexi Krupp, Jason Gregg, Jillian Mock

Birding for Solidarity: The Phoebes

Eight women decided they had enough of the sport's competitiveness, so they created a community to lift their sisters up.

If you鈥檙e in the presence of a male Eastern Phoebe, he鈥檒l let you know. The small sooty-brown flycatcher cues his own arrival with a that rings out from the woodlands. The female phoebe, meanwhile, keeps a low profile among the branches. Her nest, which she builds on her own, is an engineering marvel: a woven collage of mud, moss, grass, and fur.

But her subtle strength and fierce independence tend to go unappreciated鈥攁 feeling the Phoebes, in South Florida, know all too well and are trying to amend, one mindful excursion at a time.

The founders of the Phoebes first met on a muggy October morning in 2017 during a fall-migration walk led by record-breaking birder Noah Strycker, the听, and Leica Store Miami. The women hailed from a range of backgrounds鈥攂iology, education, culinary and visual arts鈥攂ut they felt an instant connection through their shared love of nature and kindred perspectives. They spent much of the hike along the Biscayne Bay laughing, filling in the pauses between sightings with chatter and queries for Strycker, who responded deftly and supportively. By the end of the day, the women knew they鈥檇 experienced something different from the typical ID- and list-obsessed outing. They wanted to build on the collaborative spirit and decided to meet again.

Over dinner at Kirsten Hines鈥 house in Miami a few nights later, the ladies vented about their frustrations with 鈥渟erious鈥 birding: the competitiveness, the tendency to dismiss common species, the contempt toward newbies, the mansplaining. They decided to embrace their own style of birding鈥攐ne that moved at its own pace, dwelled more on the animals and their environments, and above all, accepted any woman with an interest in Aves, no matter her skill or knowledge.

But what to call this sisterhood? The women settled on the Phoebes, in part because the drab songbird is often overshadowed by Florida鈥檚 tropical species. The name had feminist connotations as well: It paid homage to Phoebe Snetsinger, the driven, whip-smart birder who documented 8,300 avian species in her fifties and sixties, and Phoebe, a Titan from Greek mythology whose name signifies brightness.听

鈥淚t was a powerful, feminine night,鈥 says Leticia de Mello Bueno, one of the founding eight, who is now a communications manager at 探花精选. 鈥淚 felt queenly. There was the sense that something significant was happening through us.鈥澨

Fast forward a year and a half, and the Phoebes are on the ground doing exactly what they set out to accomplish. The club at different locations in Miami-Dade County, including urban parks and beachside oases. Each walk draws an average of 20 participants, and the group鈥檚 mailing list includes 70 or so members.

The听field听trips offer a built-in space for empathizing and networking. Members are encouraged to take breaks to ask questions, work out basic IDs, and revel in the details of any species, avian or not. (A WhatsApp group allows them to keep up the conversation and share personal milestones in between meetups.) The women keep a list of all birds they see or hear to help track population trends , but otherwise they don鈥檛 tally species competitively.


It鈥檚 an approach that might generally appeal to more women than men. Both genders go birding with roughly the same levels of interest but with drastically different styles, according to a peer-reviewed study . The researcher surveyed 954 members of the American Birding Association, 65 percent of whom were male. They found that men focused more on listing and traveled farther to see rare birds; women, on the other hand, birded closer to home and reported higher personal enrichment.

Hines stresses that everyone can channel the Phoebes鈥 mission and broaden their birding horizons, regardless of gender. 鈥淲e are not anti-male,鈥 she says. 鈥淲e wanted to create a community for women that was pro-environment, and we see birds as a gateway drug for that.鈥澨

This perspective drives the group鈥檚 second calling: conservation. Miami, and Florida in general, is plagued by a slew of environmental issues, from pollution to invasive species to, of course, . The Phoebes have taken part in two Christmas Bird Counts, volunteered with the Cape Florida Banding Station, and hosted native-plant walks鈥攁ctivities that have piqued some younger recruits鈥 interest in conservation careers. Even the monthly birding outings can be a form of stewardship. 鈥淟isting [on eBird] is really helpful in understanding the impact of climate change and which species are going one way or another,鈥 says Hines. The Phoebes help compile data on avian migration, breeding fluxes, and behaviors that might otherwise go unnoticed.

Which brings us back to the female听bird that inspired Hines and her friends to transform their beloved pastime. History has it that it was the first species to be banded in North America; in 1804 John James 探花精选 onto five nestlings in Pennsylvania, then watched for them to return every spring.

The Phoebes also watch for the return of their namesake in Florida every winter. True to form, they celebrate each and every one they find.

Birding for Social Change: Feminist Bird Club

Molly Adams wanted everyone to be treated fairly, so her club builds justice into its mission.

As a solo female birder in New York City, Molly Adams has felt unsafe on more than one occasion. So in the fall of 2016, she began the to create a space where women, trans individuals, people of color, and other marginalized groups could experience birding in a protected environment. 鈥淚t only takes one individual who exhibits sexist, racist, or homophobic behavior to ruin the entire experience,鈥 she says. What鈥檚 more, she wanted to build a network that would advocate for a larger purpose鈥攖hough she didn鈥檛 know exactly what that would be.

Then Donald Trump was elected president.

鈥淚mmediately, I went into panic mode,鈥 Adams says. Like in the aftermath of the election, she rallied to the aid of refugees, reproductive-health advocates, and others subjected to the attacks that followed Trump鈥檚 campaign and policies. In a few months, the Feminist Bird Club raised $300 for Planned Parenthood鈥檚 New York chapter by selling patches embroidered with Painted Buntings. The response convinced her that there was an appetite for social activism within the birding community.

Three years later, Adams鈥 vision is stronger than ever. What started as a series of late-morning and afternoon walks with friends has exploded into an advocacy powerhouse for birders, with chapters in five U.S. cities, Toronto, and Buenos Aires.

Thanks to articles in the and by the , the 20 slots for walks in New York City now fill up almost as soon as they鈥檙e posted. While participation is open to anyone, the goal is to elevate marginalized groups. It鈥檚 not that other birding outfits like the Brooklyn Bird Club and New York City 探花精选 aren鈥檛 inclusive, she stresses: The fact that inclusivity is built into the Feminist Bird Club鈥檚 mission just makes it more appealing to novices.

Take Kasia Chmielinski, for example. The mixed-raced birder, who identifies as nonbinary, wanted to join a local group to hone their skills; but the meet-ups they attended were monopolized by men.

That wasn鈥檛 the case during their first Feminist Bird Club meet-up in Washington Square Park last fall, which highlighted Georgia Silvera-Seamans,听. 鈥淚t's important for me to be involved in organizations that are led by women and people of color, or at least have a strong showing of them,鈥 Chmielinski say. 鈥淚 think it changes the nature of the conversation; it changes the nature of the group. It feels more inclusive.鈥 听

Adams welcomes cis white men to attend events, too. If it looks as though they鈥檙e going to fill up too many slots, she just convinces them to sign up for another date. On the walks themselves, she encourages anyone stealing the good views or trying to school others to take a step back.

As the club鈥檚 popularity has grown, so have the funds it has raised for various causes. Each year Adams conceptualizes an iron-on patch that features a different bird and sells for $10. For the first two years she covered the costs out of pocket in order to donate every cent of the proceeds. This year, a small grant from the Safina Center, a conservation nonprofit, has helped defray the expense. Still, Adams works tirelessly to get hundreds of them out to donors鈥攁 task she assumes on top of her day job as the advocacy and outreach manager for .

Her efforts have paid off. In 2017 the Feminist Bird Club donated $1,000 each to the New York Abortion Access Fund and the Women鈥檚 Initiative; in 2018, it donated $4,700 to Black Lives Matter. This year, the money will be split between Pueblo Sin Fronteras, a volunteer organization that helps migrants and refugees safely cross the border from Mexico, and Native Youth Sexual Health Network, a reproductive-resource group led by and for Indigenous youth.

When it comes to choosing where to donate, Adams says that she consults with the other Feminist Bird Club chapters. 鈥淯nfortunately, there isn't a shortage of groups of people that [the Trump] administration is attacking,鈥 she says.

Patches aren鈥檛 the only means of fundraising for the club. During last year, the New York City chapter enlisted supporters to pledge money for each species spotted and brought in $460 for the Sex Workers Outreach Project. The count took place during peak spring migration, Adams recalls, and people were excited to see Scarlet Tanagers and Yellow Warblers for the first time that season. Toward the end of the walk, the group also spotted a female Cerulean Warbler.

鈥淔olks were so enamored by the pale blue color of the female we found,鈥 Adams says. It was much subtler than the flashy male birds鈥攁 nuance that both beginner and expert birders could admire.

While Adams is proud of how quickly the club has grown, she wants to encourage members to make their own change. 鈥淚 think it's really important for them to go back into the other birding communities and maybe bring some of the ideals of the Feminist Bird Club to them,鈥 she says. Now that they鈥檝e found their voices as advocates, they can get other birders to wield their binoculars for justice.

Birding for Economic Empowerment: Uganda Women Birders

Judith Mirembe faced uphill odds as a bird guide, so she's training others to break into the career.

Growing up in western Uganda, Judith Mirembe鈥檚 parents told her stories of the , or Kanyamunyu. If the little black and white bird appeared in their compound early in the morning, the family would know to expect guests. When she was four听years old, they saw a wagtail three times in one week. 鈥淐oincidentally, we received visitors,鈥 Mirembe says. 鈥淭hat is how my love for the birds was born.鈥

Birding became Mirembe鈥檚 passion. She鈥檇 watch flocks rise from the trees in nearby forest patches and fly to the crops surrounding her home. But she didn鈥檛 consider pursuing her favorite creatures professionally until she enrolled in a听university in Kampala in 2012. Even as she was working toward a degree in environmental science, she worried about career prospects after graduation. Well-paying jobs are scarce in Uganda, and the market would be even tougher for her: The unemployment rate for women in their twenties and thirties as that for men.

Mirembe approached Herbert Byaruhanga, the managing director of and her brother-in-law. She began training part time with him to build her birding skills while juggling her schoolwork. She couldn鈥檛 afford to buy high-quality binoculars during her apprenticeship and was grateful when a female tourist from Australia eventually gifted her a pair.

Mirembe was armed with the skills and gear she needed, but the odds were still against her. For one thing, across Africa, birders generally, and bird guides especially, skew male; in Byaruhanga鈥檚 20 years in the business, he鈥檚 encountered an estimated 120 male guides and only 30 female ones. What鈥檚 more, clients or employers might hold her gender against her. 鈥淏irdwatching has become popular in Uganda, but the woman鈥檚 place is still seen as belonging to the kitchen,鈥 Mirembe says.

With Byaruhanga鈥檚 encouragement, she decided to form a group dedicated to empowering jobless female college graduates to break through the male ranks of the industry. She recruited 10 ladies and launched the club in 2013. Over the years, dozens of employed members of the group have helped to teach fresh guides and connect them with tour companies across the country. The costs of training and gear are largely covered by scholarships and donations. In 2015 the club received $30,000 from the United Nations Development Programme. In addition, they鈥檝e received funds from friends, international and local fairs, and the Uganda Wildlife Authority.

National Geographic Field Guide to the Birds of North America

Male + Male

National Geographic Backyard Guide to the Birds of North America

Male + Male

Peterson Field Guide to Birds of North America

Male

The Sibley Guide to Birds, 2nd Edition (and all Sibley books)

Male

The Stokes Field Guide to the Birds of North America

Male + Female

The Crossley ID Guide: Eastern Birds

Male

Kaufman Field Guide to Birds of North America

Male (+ 1 Male and 2 Female contributors)

Birds: A Fully Illustrated, Authoritative and Easy-to-Use Guide

Male + Male

Click each top-selling field guide to reveal the genders of the authors.

Uganda Women Birders currently has 50 new and longtime members, 30 of whom are employed by tour groups. On average, Mirembe says the guides can earn $1,200 for a two-week expedition. (An annual salary would be roughly $5,000, based on eight or nine trips.) Compare that to the $600 the average Ugandan makes in one year, and the benefits of the business are clear.

In addition to helping members achieve economic independence, the club is working to change societal attitudes around gender equality by hosting presentations on how female guides can be breadwinners. 鈥淥nly 2 out of 10 women we train get support from their partners after marriage to continue birding,鈥 Mirembe says. 鈥淭his has to change.鈥

Support is also needed to get the women through the rigorous training period. Mirembe, who now works as a bird-population-monitoring coordinator at the nonprofit , says that it takes at least two years to acquire the skills and confidence for bird guiding鈥攁nd even then, the graduates aren鈥檛 guaranteed a stable career and income. After seeing the high dropout rates of club members, Mirembe realized the group needed a more reliable job engine. So this past August she launched a birding company, Women Adventures Africa, to employ women who trained with the club. 鈥淭his company will give women hope that if they train hard, they will have a job at the end of the day,鈥 Mirembe says.

Women Adventures Africa is still in in its infancy, but Mirembe is committed to hiring only female freelance guides and paying each of them $80 to $100 per day, until she can take on a regular staff. The target clientele, she says, are travelers who believe in the guides鈥櫶齥nowledge and leadership and want to elevate it.

Mirembe recognizes that the appeal of female guides isn鈥檛 limited to Uganda; she鈥檚 helped women in Kenya and Rwanda launch their own economically motivated clubs in recent months. 鈥淚t gives me a lot of encouragement to keep moving, as we are building a chain,鈥 Mirembe says. 鈥淢y hope is in building stronger networks听that [we] will learn from each other and have competent women birders to effectively conduct tours continent-wide.鈥 听

Linda Alila, an ornithology intern at the Nairobi National Museum, is the co-founder of the . To her, the new venture is a way to not only earn a living from birding, but also contribute to avian research and conservation. 鈥淲omen birders will have an opportunity to be citizen scientists through our efforts,鈥 she says. 鈥淚f we understand birds鈥 ecological and economical importance, we will help in sustainably conserving them.鈥 One way to achieve that, Alila says, is by encouraging the use of the global , which allows birders to map their sightings and track regional migration patterns.

Like the Uganda club, Kenya Women Birders supports 50 passionate members, including university students, tour operators, leisure birders, and guides. They face many of the same challenges that Mirembe has encountered, but thanks to the ground she鈥檚 broken, the path will be smoother for the women birding behind her.

Birding for Respect: Biggest Week

Kimberly Kaufman noticed all-male lineups at festivals, so she headlined hers with expert women.

At a birding festival in Florida several years ago, Kimberly Kaufman was listening to a panel鈥攐stensibly the region鈥檚 birding experts鈥攄iscuss avifauna and its conservation. She looked at the slate of all men sitting on stage before her, and then at the gathered crowd, where she recognized several women with deep knowledge of local species. As the men spoke, she felt the urge to say something grow stronger and stronger鈥攗ntil finally Kaufman pushed down her discomfort, stood up, and asked: 鈥淲hy are all the panelists men?鈥 Onlookers gasped, murmured, and gradually broke into applause.

The simple query generated a shocked response because Kaufman had questioned a long-standing norm. Men fill the vast majority of speaker slots at the country鈥檚 leading birding festivals. But not at the , the annual festival in northwest Ohio that Kaufman co-founded 10 years ago, and especially not last year.

To attract tens of thousands of lens-toting enthusiasts to admire migrating warblers as they pause before crossing Lake Erie, she books birding鈥檚 biggest stars (including her husband, Kenn Kaufman) to speak during the 10-day festival, as well as several lesser-known experts, including accomplished women and trans people. When planning the 2018 event, she noticed a 鈥済roundswell鈥 of awareness around sexism in birding, so she decided to focus on women even more than usual, booking them for . (This year are women.)

Tiffany Adams presented on urban birding, Ashli Gorbet told stories of migration science, Catherine Hamilton and Kelly Riccetti taught field sketching, and a panel of 鈥淧ower Women鈥 recounted their experiences breaking the Big Year glass ceiling.

Kaufman believes it鈥檚 important to foster the change she wants to see. It鈥檚 a philosophy she has embodied throughout her notable career in ornithology, from her early days as a bird bander, as the executive director of (BSBO), an inspirer听for clubs for young birders in 20 states, and more recently as the founder of the Biggest Week. She鈥檚 watched with satisfaction as issues of diversity and inclusion have skyrocketed to the fore of her industry. And she鈥檚 using her power to elevate new voices and overlooked experts, many of whom are female.

For Adams, who has been trying to break into an ornithological career for the past few years, presenting at last year鈥檚 festival provided a springboard to other opportunities, including press attention around her vision of urban birding and, this month, a presenting gig at a prominent environmental-education conference. 鈥淚t gave me hope that if I can do this, if I can speak at such a prestigious engagement, what else can I do?鈥 Adams says. 鈥淚t opened my eyes to the possibility that being a birder and building a career around it is not a fairy tale.鈥

BIRDFEST!

  • Kachemak Bay Shorebird Festival
  • Monterey Bay Birding Festival
  • Atlanta Bird Fest
  • Florida Birding & Nature Festival
  • CVBC SYMPOSIUM
  • Wings Over Water Wildlife Festival
  • Alaska Bald Eagle Festival
  • Rio Grande Valley Birding Festival
  • Godwit Days
  • Yakima River Canyon Bird Fest
  • Indiana Dunes Birding Festival
  • Biggest Week In American Birding
  • Acadia Birding Festival
  • Festival Of Birds
Tap or hover to show birding festivals that featured women in their lineup last year.

Kaufman鈥檚 interest in helping lift others up stems from her experience as an outsider in the birding world. She grew up on a farm in northwest Ohio, where she spent her free time poking through nearby woods, swamps, and marshes. She felt a deep connection to nature generally but didn鈥檛 take special notice of birds. 鈥淢y family was so poor, there were times when my parents were struggling to feed the five of us [kids], much less a feeder,鈥 Kaufman says.

She didn鈥檛 catch the spark until her late twenties when she spied a group of striking yellow birds outside an office window鈥American Goldfinches, she was told. 鈥淭he entire course of my life changed in that moment,鈥 says Kaufman, who owned a home- and office-cleaning business at the time. 鈥淚f something like a blazing-gold American Goldfinch has been under my nose my whole life and I missed it, what else is out there?鈥

She soon began volunteering with the state wildlife agency to monitor Bald Eagles nesting near her home. Unsated, she trained as a bird bander and worked as a researcher at BSBO. There she had several masterful female mentors, but at conferences she was often the lone woman in a group of men. 鈥淣ot a single one of them would assume that I was a fellow bander,鈥 she recalls; they presumed she was someone鈥檚 girlfriend. But she found that her knowledge far surpassed that of the average bander, thanks to the high volume of birds she handled at BSBO, and that realization gave her the confidence to assert herself when men tried to dismiss her.

鈥淚 see this happen so often, that women get dissed in the field and they don鈥檛 say anything; they don鈥檛 speak up for themselves,鈥 Kaufman says. Using these moments to start constructive conversations is important, she explains, both to establish female expertise and to prevent further indignities. 鈥淵ou don鈥檛 have to be rude to say, 鈥楬ow funny that you would think that I鈥檓 not the field trip leader鈥攊s that because I鈥檓 a woman?鈥 鈥 she suggests. 鈥淚t鈥檚 not just about teaching people to ID birds, but also teaching people how to be better human beings.鈥

Her approach has boosted many young birders, especially female. 鈥淵ounger women in their teens can fall into confidence traps, where even though they have this expertise, they don鈥檛 feel like they do compared to their male counterparts,鈥 says Auriel Fournier, a bird researcher at Mississippi State University who met Kaufman, her 鈥渂ird mom,鈥 at BSBO when she was 10 years old. 鈥淜im鈥檚 been really good about providing the mentoring and support to give those women the ability to take those next steps, whether it鈥檚 leading field trips at the birding festival or organizing talks at the Ohio Young Birders Conference.鈥

While Kaufman is thrilled to see women听gaining prominence and is dedicated to doing her part to elevate them at the Biggest Week and beyond, she stresses the importance of supporting anyone with a birdy passion鈥攆emale, male, or transgender. 鈥淚f we just treat everyone with respect and the benefit of the doubt from the start,鈥 she says, 鈥渨e鈥檒l all do better.鈥